Houston Astros general manager Jeff Luhnow refused to give up any of our top prospects in any worthwhile trade prior to the trading deadline which feels a little bittersweet to me. On the one hand the Astros future is going to be amazing and they will be stacked with a ton of young talent. This could be a team that constantly wins the American League West division title for the foreseeable future. No team in the division right now really strikes any long-term fear into me: Mariners, Rangers, Angels or Athletics.
Top outfield prospects Derek Fisher and Kyle Tucker are staying with the Astros. As will top pitching prospects Francis Martes, Forrest Whitley and Franklin Perez. Slugging third baseman, J.D. Davis, who can also play multiple positions, is also not going anywhere. Both Fisher and Martes are already on the big league roster. We didn't even trade Daz Cameron, a young and promising center fielder, who's father was a long-time MLB player.
I thought for sure the Astros would have dealt at least three or four of those guys...
At least picked up Brad Hand from the Padres and Lance Lynn from the Cardinals.
I'd have even overpaid some prospects for Orioles closer Zach Britton if I were the Astros GM.
The Orioles wanted Kyle Tucker in any package deal but Jeff Luhnow was unwilling to do it.
Meanwhile the Los Angeles Dodgers acquired Yu Darvish. The Yankees acquired Sonny Gray. The Cubs acquired Jose Quintana, Justin Wilson and even a backup catcher in Avila. The Red Sox added another closer in Addison Reed despite having the best closer in the game. Even the Nationals added Sean Doolittle, Ryan Madson and Brandon Kintzler. The Diamondbacks and Rockies, the two wild-card teams in the National League that will play a one game playoff (one of them will be one and done), both made a flurry of moves over the past few weeks. They didn't just wait until the final minute.
The other legitimate contenders in baseball are "going all out" and trying to win the 2017 World Series this October. While the Astros seem content to just be a playoff team, year in and year out, for the next several years. Why am I not super excited? It's not like it's a bad thing to want to be a solid ball club for a long time but for a franchise that has never won a World Series it seems a little disheartening to me.
I wouldn't be terribly upset right now if Dallas Keuchel and Lance McCullers Jr. weren't struggling to regain their all-star and ace-like form, along with Carlos Correa (out until September) and George Springer also being on the disabled list. But we're clearly hurting right now with four all-stars that either aren't playing or not playing up to par.
We clearly needed some help. The only trade the Astros made was for Francisco Liriano and his 5.88 ERA but was the best we could do? We gave up veteran outfielder Nori Aoki and young outfielder Teoscar Hernandez. The trade makes more sense to clear room for Derek Fisher on the active 25-man roster. Liriano has a .230 batting average against lefties so naturally he'll be a limited lefty specialist for us. Tony Sipp (our only other lefty reliever), who has been horrible himself this season, has a slightly higher ERA than Liriano (6.39) but Sipp is actually better against lefties with a .217 batting average against.
Hopefully come October we'll have a healthy roster for the playoffs and I can feel excited about a potential World Series run. I still think we're capable of winning the American League this year but a lot depends on our health. And clearly, Keuchel, McCullers Jr. and McHugh will have to be our "big three" to carry us in the starting rotation. Mike Fiers or Charlie Morton can be used as a #4 starter in a 7-game playoff series. Brad Peacock has been a nice surprise this year as both a starting pitcher and reliever. Everybody in our bullpen has to step up once the playoffs start, especially Ken Giles, Chris Devenski and Will Harris. And our hitting has to become a great offense again.
Maybe I'll feel better in October when the playoffs start. If we're healthy we may have a chance. But for now I feel dejected and disappointed. I just want to finish July tonight and then hurry up and finish the month of August. By September I pray for Carlos Correa to come back and dominate. The 2017 Houston Astros could have been a special team. They still can, but clearly our front office is just focused on having a good team for many years to come. 2018-2019-2020-2021-2022, etc.. etc... I'd rather have went "all out" to try and win a World Series title in 2017 like the other good teams are trying to do.
This post was edited by Madmartigan on Jul 31 2017 03:40pm