I remember the advice of a uni prof I had was to focus on compound movements only, and don't even bother with isolated stuff except maybe one or two exercises. He had string arms. The people he trained had string arms. He was all about crossfit and track and field. He had a motto: "I don't want to look big. I want to be able to perform in sports." He played tennis, soccer, and ran. He cited lots of articles to back up his theories, and his class was based on his own textbook. He chose studies that confirmed his own opinions. Most of what he had to say was true, except when it came to hypertrophy and strength training. He mainly just knew about flexibility and distance training (and big focus on VO2 max). Bit of a nutjob. He could run circles around me though, much fitter than me overall, just no muscle on him.
I've had my fair share of failures with exercise and lifting, but I think instinct training is something that a lot of people avoid because they're afraid... maybe they don't know what to do & need regimented advice, or maybe they are afraid that if they don't have a plan that they won't give it their all in the gym. Me, if you're feeling another set, go for it. Make it a dropset if you have to. Maybe up the weight for 1-2 reps first. Do what feels right sometimes. Flip side: If you hate squats (I hate squats b/c I need to improve my back & core & legs still, and my cardiovascular system), maybe stick to something more regimented and hold yourself to your plan.
The whole "12 reps is killing your gains" or "5 reps for strength", or whatever, is stuff I've somewhat thrown out the window. Great for shaking up the workouts if you're stuck, and probably great for someone taking their gains really really seriously. I don't *not* do that stuff, but I tend toward instinct training for 50%+ of my workouts. I have a preplanned idea of what I'll do, and I'll even do exercises that don't keep the pump going (ex. bent over rear delt flies), but for example if dips are hitting my shoulders funny... I'll find something else right away. Or I might just focus on negatives on the dips only. I won't force myself thru something if I know it's not cutting it for the workout.
Instinct training is how I put on a good amount of mass on my biceps. It's how I made gains on my pullups. I started doing things that felt right. Straight bar curls felt right, dumbbell curls never did it for me as my 1st bicep exercise of the day. Negatives on pullups felt right. After hitting things that felt right, I saw gains, and I could move forward better. If I want to put on some gains on my pullup, I do weighted negatives on pullups (but I still do regular pullups). Find stuff that resonates with you (but don't be that idiot who does 30+ reps for 6 sets of an exercise because it burns... that's not the same as a pump.) I remember listening to the Hodgetwins about how they put most of their size on by ending before going to failure (they mentioned that in one vid, I bet they contradicted that in several other vids); I think in most cases, for someone with a general goal of health & aesthetics, failure is usually your target on a set.
This post was edited by Canadian_Man on Mar 29 2017 06:38pm