Quote (duffman316 @ Jan 19 2015 10:32am)
i'm not saying you're right or wrong, just that the form of your arguments are flawed because you base it on arbitrary definitions - and yes they are arbitrary
there's no reason for anyone that doesn't follow your particular sect of christianity to reject other christians as not being true christians for not sharing what you believe to be core beliefs
christianity is not well defined
There are standards for being called a Christian, or a Muslim, or a Buddhist, or a naturalist, or a Marxist, or an anarchist, etc etc. A person with Buddhist beliefs who identifies as a Christian is not a Christian. That is not a no true scotsman fallacy.
Quote (Scaly @ Jan 19 2015 10:39am)
Herpaderpderp. Over and over and over. Reread that post on atheist forums and try and work out the fallacy you're making about the evidence you think you have to say that you're not making the other fallacy.
While you're working your way out of fallacy-ception I'm gonna catch some Z's. If you don't get it by the time I get up you probably never will and this will have to remain a point of contention between us until such a time as you learn to be rational.
Goodnight.
No substance, just claims I am wrong. Not surprising.
It's late in the morning where I'm at.
Quote (duffman316 @ Jan 19 2015 10:40am)
haven't been keeping up with what it is exactly el shadday believes but it looks like you agree that you cannot reject mormonism as non christian? they do consider jesus to be son of god which you consider to be essential to being a christian?
I don't understand Mormonism enough to have an opinion on whether they are a legitimate Christian denomination.
This post was edited by IceMage on Jan 19 2015 09:48am