d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > Entertainment Room > Anime > Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood > Question
12Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 1,241
Joined: Jun 25 2011
Gold: Locked
Oct 18 2014 10:09am
Oi,

I was just wondering how present the comedy is in this anime. Tbh I don't really like comedy in movies/anime in general as I think it breaks the atmosphere and immersion. This is why I like shows like Berserk or Shigurui and since I can't find anymore like those I was wondering about FMA:B . Do you think I'd like it based on what I just said?

Ty
Member
Posts: 7,995
Joined: May 27 2007
Gold: 36,570.00
Oct 18 2014 10:23am
no, probably not
Member
Posts: 1,241
Joined: Jun 25 2011
Gold: Locked
Oct 18 2014 10:25am
Quote (mortwatcher @ Oct 18 2014 06:23pm)
no, probably not


Crap, reviews looked great :(
Member
Posts: 5,250
Joined: Apr 20 2008
Gold: 121.03
Oct 18 2014 10:26am
love the comedy in this series had me laughing more then any comedy in the past years

This post was edited by JudgeTedd on Oct 18 2014 10:26am
Member
Posts: 1,241
Joined: Jun 25 2011
Gold: Locked
Oct 18 2014 10:30am
Well.. guess ill just try the claymore anime once again, the first few episodes felt really cheap though, and characters are very bland

Always looking for some serious, medievalish anime btw, dobt hesitate to pm
Member
Posts: 26,684
Joined: Jan 29 2011
Gold: Locked
Oct 18 2014 10:58am
Quote (m0hawk @ Oct 18 2014 10:30am)
Well.. guess ill just try the claymore anime once again, the first few episodes felt really cheap though, and characters are very bland

Always looking for some serious, medievalish anime btw, dobt hesitate to pm


I always felt like Claymore was meant to feel sort of "bland." It's a pretty hopeless setting. If you're only a few episodes into it though I'd recommend toughing it out. Far as FMA:B goes, I hate that stupid cat-face humor as well but it's dark enough to offset those weird childish moments.
Member
Posts: 1,241
Joined: Jun 25 2011
Gold: Locked
Oct 18 2014 11:05am
Quote (Grime @ Oct 18 2014 06:58pm)
I always felt like Claymore was meant to feel sort of "bland." It's a pretty hopeless setting. If you're only a few episodes into it though I'd recommend toughing it out. Far as FMA:B goes, I hate that stupid cat-face humor as well but it's dark enough to offset those weird childish moments.


Ya I get what ur saying, i believe i stopped watching when the claymores were challenging each other and there was those stupid fight scenes and crappy dialogs. In fact when watching claymore I can't help thinking "wow, berserk is so much better than this..." but maybe its just the beginning thats a bit boring. Ill give fmab a try anyway since it is so praised by ppl
Member
Posts: 26,684
Joined: Jan 29 2011
Gold: Locked
Oct 18 2014 11:32am
Quote (m0hawk @ Oct 18 2014 11:05am)
Ya I get what ur saying, i believe i stopped watching when the claymores were challenging each other and there was those stupid fight scenes and crappy dialogs. In fact when watching claymore I can't help thinking "wow, berserk is so much better than this..." but maybe its just the beginning thats a bit boring. Ill give fmab a try anyway since it is so praised by ppl


Berserk is my favorite show of all time and the only reason I got into Claymore was because niggas were like "yo if you want more sword violence check out Claymore." Of course if you're watching it and can't help but compare it to Berserk, it'll feel like a pretty underwhelming show. It gets interesting though, I promise.

Edit: I'd never even heard of Shigurui but that shit looks awesome. I might have to check that out instead of what I was planning to watch.

This post was edited by Grime on Oct 18 2014 11:33am
Member
Posts: 20,231
Joined: May 30 2008
Gold: 24.40
Oct 18 2014 02:19pm
try sword of the stranger and ninja scroll (ive only seen the movie, not sure how good the show is)
Member
Posts: 1,241
Joined: Jun 25 2011
Gold: Locked
Oct 18 2014 02:30pm
Do check out shigurui then, even if you don't "like" it, the visuals, music and armosphere are worth it imo, plus its only 12 episodes

Edit: ty Marley :) already know of ninja scrolls, will check out the other

This post was edited by m0hawk on Oct 18 2014 02:34pm
Go Back To Anime Topic List
12Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll