d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Political & Religious Debate > Is Farming Sustainable In The Developed World? > Opinions Dating Back To Founding Fathers
12Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 33,488
Joined: Oct 9 2008
Gold: 2,617.52
Aug 11 2014 02:03pm
Found this nugget and thought it framed the issue nicely.

http://www.startribune.com/opinion/commentaries/202778751.html

Quote
The founders knew what they were up against. Our human penchant for selfish, shortsighted behavior was alive and well in their day. By 1818, Virginia’s once-fertile farmland had been ruined.

When James Madison addressed landowners who’d gathered to discuss the mass exodus of farmers to the greener pastures of Kentucky, his first task was consciousness-raising. Not all of his listeners were as up on their classical philosophy as the former president, much less on the latest scientific discoveries in biology and horticulture.

In today’s America, a farmer’s only hedges against risk are the futures market and various government subsidies. Farmers depend on synthetic chemical fertilizers (instead of the fancy manures that Jefferson, Adams and Washington in particular discussed with the ardor of any modern wine snob) and on genetic tinkering to keep pests and weeds at bay.


Quote
Genetically modified organisms and big machines aren’t inherently evil. But we need to take a step back to evaluate the pros and cons of what a monoculture-based system is doing to us and our planet.

Can corn and soybeans feed the world? Actually, these crops mainly feed livestock (not the most efficient protein source). They also make ethanol (not the most efficient fuel) and corn syrup sweeteners (not the best human energy source).

Meanwhile, soybean production is stealing land from biodiverse rainforests in Brazil that are our first line of defense against climate change. Oil-based fertilizers are aggravating an already grave shortage of clean water, and pesticides are proving toxic to bees and butterflies. Colony Collapse Disorder threatens bee pollinators without whose services our food system itself could collapse.


Imo, its heartening to know that farmer's markets are still alive and well in some parts of the country.

And also a shameless plug to help out organic farmers if you are so inclined

https://petitions.whitehouse.gov/petition/president-obama-dont-let-usda-undermine-governance-and-integrity-organic-food-and-agriculture/9q8kG08S
Member
Posts: 33,855
Joined: Jul 2 2007
Gold: 633.87
Aug 11 2014 02:07pm
Organic is a rich man's luxury. The vast majority of people survive on the wonders of GMO and modern agriculture.

To criticize responsibly you need to have a replacement ready, we are never going back to the age of starvation.
Member
Posts: 33,488
Joined: Oct 9 2008
Gold: 2,617.52
Aug 11 2014 02:25pm
Quote (bogie160 @ Aug 11 2014 04:07pm)
Organic is a rich man's luxury. The vast majority of people survive on the wonders of GMO and modern agriculture.

To criticize responsibly you need to have a replacement ready, we are never going back to the age of starvation.


Its a valid counter point, but I also feel people do have options that they don't consider. And also the fact that starvation will always exist. I personally ran events to distribute food and supplies among homeless individuals. In our area, upwards of 50% of them didn't even want our help. I think some people simply don't want to be helped regardless of how many chances you offer them.

People can choose to subsist at a lower than optimal standard of living, living where consumer choices don't include omnipresent luxuries like big houses, computers, televisions, children. and smart phones. Many people often choose these luxuries over those that promise a more long term benefit, better investments like food that doesn't slowly lower their standard of living over time and also for future generations.
Member
Posts: 77,534
Joined: Nov 30 2008
Gold: 500.00
Aug 11 2014 02:27pm
i've heard of some claims about pushing towards vegetarianism to better feed the world as meat is an inefficient use of grain and if more people eat meat we have substantially less to feed everyone with

fairly effective vegetarian propaganda imo

This post was edited by duffman316 on Aug 11 2014 02:27pm
Member
Posts: 63,030
Joined: Jul 15 2005
Gold: 152.00
Aug 11 2014 02:49pm
Yes it should be. What isn't is factory farming.

Quote (duffman316 @ Aug 11 2014 04:27pm)
i've heard of some claims about pushing towards vegetarianism to better feed the world as meat is an inefficient use of grain and if more people eat meat we have substantially less to feed everyone with

fairly effective vegetarian propaganda imo


effective and true
Member
Posts: 61,375
Joined: Mar 14 2006
Gold: 10.77
Aug 11 2014 07:06pm
centralized factory farms are not sustainable. Localized community farms are. That's where the future is going or people are going to starve.
Member
Posts: 61,375
Joined: Mar 14 2006
Gold: 10.77
Aug 11 2014 07:16pm
Quote (bogie160 @ Aug 11 2014 01:07pm)
Organic is a rich man's luxury. The vast majority of people survive on the wonders of GMO and modern agriculture.

To criticize responsibly you need to have a replacement ready, we are never going back to the age of starvation.


This is really not true.

First, organic is a farming method that is easily deployed and even the UN FAO has stated that localized organic farming is the only way to sustainably feed the world. The main factors on cost are demand, simple branding, and artificially low supply. If there were a community controlled small organic farm around every street corner, cost would diminish into almost nothing.

Second, the vast majority of GMO crops (corn and soy make up the majority by quite a bit) are not being used as staple foods. Most are being used to create ethanol or going to animal feed. If you're referring to Borlaug's dwarf wheat, that does not fit into the category of transgenics or genetic engineering, it's an enhanced conventional breed.

And modern capitalist agriculture is a root cause of starvation. It pushes farmers into growing cash crops while people all around are starving to death, ruins the land, and destroys economic competition and eventually farmers in poor nations, which leads to even more starvation.

This post was edited by inkanddagger on Aug 11 2014 07:18pm
Member
Posts: 33,488
Joined: Oct 9 2008
Gold: 2,617.52
Aug 11 2014 07:34pm
Quote (Voyaging @ Aug 11 2014 04:49pm)
effective and true


Vouch that

In simple terms, it takes like 5 pounds of vegetables to make 1 pound of edible meat.
Member
Posts: 57,901
Joined: Dec 3 2008
Gold: 285.00
Aug 11 2014 07:39pm
Human society will be post-food soon enough for a bland future.
Member
Posts: 63,030
Joined: Jul 15 2005
Gold: 152.00
Aug 11 2014 07:45pm
Quote (Skinned @ Aug 11 2014 09:39pm)
Human society will be post-food soon enough for a bland future.


http://www.soylent.me/

:P
Go Back To Political & Religious Debate Topic List
12Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll