Quote (SteveSpeed @ Jul 15 2012 03:17am)

He doesnt choke atleast he puts the points on the board its not like he throws for 100 yds 2ints and no tds his team is no where near complimentary to him.  Guaranteed Peyton is a first ballot hall of fame, Eli is not.  I'd take being shrined in the hall of fame for life for personal succes than one xrta superbowl that a lesser qb got.  Trent Dilfer was better than Michal Vick, Dan Marino, Romo, Rivers, and several others with that logic.  Atleast Peyton got his ring which his hard enough.

Quote (eAiDz @ Jul 15 2012 12:47am)

He does worst actually.

Threw like 4 picks one time

Quote (Reckreation @ Jul 15 2012 04:02pm)

Which year was Peyton statistically worse then Peyton?  Please let me know.

Also who lead the most interceptions for multiple of years?

Including playoffs/regular season.

Quote (Reckreation @ Jul 15 2012 09:03pm)

Which year was Peyton statistically worst then Eli* fixed for you.

Quote (draino @ Jul 15 2012 05:15pm)

@reckreation

have you ever watched Peyton played in the playoffs comparing to Eli? Eli single handily beat the greatest team of all time, stopped them from going undefeated and stopped them again last year. Eli is clutch as fuck in the playoffs while Peyton has always choked, and his only SB win was against a QB who can't even start on the Redskins.

Quote (draino @ Jul 15 2012 06:15pm)

@reckreation

have you ever watched Peyton played in the playoffs comparing to Eli? Eli single handily beat the greatest team of all time, stopped them from going undefeated and stopped them again last year. Eli is clutch as fuck in the playoffs while Peyton has always choked, and his only SB win was against a QB who can't even start on the Redskins.

Quote (thundercock @ Jul 15 2012 10:39pm)

You know, it's fun to troll people by saying Eli>Peyton.

The problem is that Giants fans ACTUALLY BELIEVE this.