Just picked this game up today. Started playing it beat the first boss then I got taken to that new island by the bird. I'm just a little confused on where I'm supposed to go..

Do I just venture around helplessly or am I suppose to explore the whole island thing..?

you can venture around, it's "open" but closed at the same time.
typically people go up the stairs first.

I have so many questions about this game.. It's really confusing. I can hit well on one monster but then the next one I'll only hit 4 continuously.
I'm sure I'll get the hang of it eventually.

go up the stairs to a sewer type aquaduct and follow the inside untill you get to a place called the undead burg. there'll be a rat on the left right when you get inside the aquaduct so you'll know its the right way. after the undead burg the game is a little more linear for awhile. when you get to the black smith be sure to buy the repair and upgrade kits, he's in a place called the undead parish after a mini boss boar.

as far as combat. be patient and use your shield. try to get a 100% physical defense shield as soon as you can so you can study the enemies with your shield up and not end up dying.

ur not supposed to hit continuously, this isnt god of war
wait for an opening and use your head

witcher 2 is much better and requires more skill

ha

picked that game up too actually. I'm enjoying it so far.

Bought it, played it for a day, returned it for full price.

this aint fable son