I'd definitely go with skyrim.
from all the rpg ive played in past none was like skyrim.
I'd only recommend on pc though because of additional mods to use real 2048 hd effects
for example:
http://static.skyrim.nexusmods.com/downloads/images/2146-1-1322872801.jpg
story, quests, amount of things, worldmapsize, companions etc.
i love it. who loves fallout series loves oblivion/skyrim
bethesda
only things i dislike on pc are the non hd thingies (but moders mod all to hd), a shit inventory (moders did better)
and not so much enemys (modder can add enemys xD)
^^ on pc bezt, on console idk i think n cuz some quests also bugged
That is not the real game idc. lol