Quote (GreenDischarge @ Oct 22 2011 11:00am)
Just went over this with someone else.
Everything exhibits some kind of polarity - even methane.
However, things with <5 in their polarity index are generally considered non polar. There is no absolute objective "point" where things become polar or non-polar.
CHCl3 is technically non-polar, however it exhibits polarity. It is not miscible in water, but miscible with hexane.
An organic chemist will agree with this:
chcl3, ch2cl2 are not polar, at all. I Don't think Ch3Cl is polar either.
A physical chemist may differ in response.
And in general chemistry you usually take a physical chemistry approach.
No.No.No.
All chemists will agree that CHCl3, CH2Cl2, CH3Cl are polar.
However, all chemistry will also agree that none are miscible in water. They are not miscible in water because they do not form hydrogen bonds and cannot dissociate in water. Just because something is polar does not mean it is miscible in water. They must be able to form hydrogen bonds in water (or dissociate in water).
I think you are confusing "polarity" and "miscibility". because in practical approach, no chemists talk about polarity, they only care if molecules are miscible or not.
and btw, physical and organic chemistry are two different fields. The fundamental theories of chemistry remains the same for both sides, responses for such simple questions will be the same.
This post was edited by Exx on Oct 22 2011 02:20pm