d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Political & Religious Debate > Free Will? Is It An Illusion?
Prev1111213
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Views: 1894Replies: 125Track Topic
Member
Posts: 58,280
Joined: Jul 10 2006
Gold: 2,900.49
#121
Jul 23 2010 10:48pm
Quote (PlasmaSnake101 @ Jul 24 2010 04:47am)
Absolutely logical. get mad


iMad.
Member
Posts: 4,509
Joined: Jul 4 2010
Gold: 6,000.00
Warn: 10%
#122
Jul 23 2010 11:13pm
Quote (Magikarpet @ Jul 24 2010 02:18pm)
no it doesnt exist because he wont pick it


The options still there, regardless of whether he picks it.
Can you really be this ignorant?
Member
Posts: 21,920
Joined: Mar 3 2007
Gold: 5.00
#123
Jul 23 2010 11:32pm
Quote (Aurorae @ Jul 23 2010 11:15pm)
Your analogy is flawed because it doesn't take into an account omniscience.

Here is a simple demonstration to prove omniscience and free-will cannot co-exist:

There are two objects on a table: an apple and an orange.

God is omnipotent and knows with 100% accuracy you will pick up the apple.

Is it possible for you to pick up the orange?

If no - Then you don't have free-will
If yes - Then god is not omniscient, and is flawed.


In the instant that you're put forward an apple and an orange, and you pick one, how much of a percentage of choice do you have in the manner?

If not 100% then please explain what is forcing you in this instance to choose one or the other.
Member
Posts: 9,968
Joined: Mar 6 2010
Gold: 61.84
Warn: 20%
#124
Jul 24 2010 12:12am
Quote (AngelasAshes @ Jul 24 2010 12:13am)
The options still there, regardless of whether he picks it.
Can you really be this ignorant?


the option isnt there because it is impossible for him to pick it.
Member
Posts: 4,509
Joined: Jul 4 2010
Gold: 6,000.00
Warn: 10%
#125
Jul 24 2010 08:25am
Quote (Magikarpet @ Jul 24 2010 04:12pm)
the option isnt there because it is impossible for him to pick it.


No it isnt impossible to pick it, you just know he wont, the option still exists.
If i had a choice between eggs or toast every morning for a million years and picked eggs every time, it doesnt mean i didnt have the choice of toast.
Member
Posts: 9,968
Joined: Mar 6 2010
Gold: 61.84
Warn: 20%
#126
Jul 24 2010 10:51am
Quote (AngelasAshes @ Jul 24 2010 09:25am)
No it isnt impossible to pick it, you just know he wont, the option still exists.
If i had a choice between eggs or toast every morning for a million years and picked eggs every time, it doesnt mean i didnt have the choice of toast.


if you would never pick toast, it's like it doesn't exist because nothing would change if u took it away, meaning it isn't a choice, it's only a choice if you will pick it.
Go Back To Political & Religious Debate Topic List
Prev1111213
Add Reply New Topic New Poll

© 2003-2024 d2jsp  Contact