d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > d2jsp > Site Suggestions > Site Suggestions Archive > Request Mod To Close Own Trade Topic > Similar To Request Mod For Trading
Closed New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 40,183
Joined: Apr 29 2006
Gold: 20,826.51
May 20 2008 08:25am
Not too certain if this has already been pointed out, or suggested.

There is a "Request Med" link when you need for trading.
Wondering if we can get a "Request Close Thread"

Basically when we use that function, we have to post in thread items sold, ty.
Well something to that nature. Then the med can check the post, and close it
at own discretion.

This idea is only because I trade during peak times and non peak times (only 27ppl on)
and I traded a set of items and want to list some more in new posts, but then the less
than 3 topics in top 50 makes it hard.

Anyway, ty for your time in my rambling.
Member
Posts: 15,643
Joined: Aug 8 2007
Gold: 58.00
May 20 2008 08:32am
Already been suggested before, I think the general concensus was that normal users shouldn't be able to close their own topics at a whim, and that it would get tons of unnecessary requests.
Retired Moderator
Posts: 12,880
Joined: Dec 19 2006
Gold: 1,355.27
Trader: Trusted
May 20 2008 08:37am
For a start u need to notice a difference between med (mediator) and mod (moderator)
Mediators can't close topics, only trade assistants and higher are able to.
My opinion is that would only make their job harder due to larger number of requests which are really less important.
If u really need ur topic closed for any reason u can allways PM some1 from moderator team and ask for that.
And for more than 2 topics in top 50 icon_pointr.gif if u request ur topic to get closed it will still be in top 50 right? And it cont's like third topic wink.gif

Sry I am against that suggestion.
Retired Moderator
Posts: 33,313
Joined: Apr 22 2006
Gold: 6,380.00
Trader: Trusted
May 20 2008 09:31am
well , usually you ask a mod to close your topic on request if you decide to keep an item or because of the spam on this topic.

if the topic is left alone, the trade is done and nobody post on it anymore, where is the point of closing it ?

sorry, voted no sad.gif
Member
Posts: 40,183
Joined: Apr 29 2006
Gold: 20,826.51
May 20 2008 07:48pm
Quote (Napkin @ Wed, May 21 2008, 03:32am)
Already been suggested before, I think the general concensus was that normal users shouldn't be able to close their own topics at a whim, and that it would get tons of unnecessary requests.


Understand that, that is why i suggested for a mod or med to close it, if it was appropriate.
Thank you, that helps out though.

--------------SEPARATION BAR-----------------

Quote (PalysFort @ Wed, May 21 2008, 03:37am)
For a start u need to notice a difference between med (mediator) and mod (moderator)
Mediators can't close topics, only trade assistants and higher are able to.
My opinion is that would only make their job harder due to larger number of requests which are really less important.
If u really need ur topic closed for any reason u can allways PM some1 from moderator team and ask for that.
And for more than 2 topics in top 50 icon_pointr.gif if u request ur topic to get closed it will still be in top 50 right? And it cont's like third topic wink.gif

Sry I am against that suggestion.


#1 Thank you for letting me know different criteria between Mods/Meds & Trade Assistants.

#2 As for making the job harder, would it be any different to "Request Mod/Med/Trade Assitant"
and while they come to help with Sale, ask them to close thread after trade??

#3 I would think that 3 ACTIVE topics in the top 50 would count against the trade rules?, not 1 closed & 2 active.

Anyway, thank you for you information, this is good to understand these things.

--------------SEPARATION BAR-----------------

Quote (gandalf052 @ Wed, May 21 2008, 04:31am)
well , usually you ask a mod to close your topic on request if you decide to keep an item or because of the spam on this topic.

if the topic is left alone, the trade is done and nobody post on it anymore, where is the point of closing it ?

sorry, voted no sad.gif


Thank you for you response.

As I can see now from these responses, that this idea is null & void.
Anyway, thank you all (3) for spending the time to read.
Member
Posts: 8,617
Joined: Dec 30 2005
Gold: 2,735.00
Trader: Trusted
May 20 2008 09:04pm
If it really needs to be closed. You can PM a " Ta " or " Tm ". Having this " Request close thread " will be making them work more. To my opinion, everything is fine at the moment. I thought your idea would be pretty good, but those 2 points I made knocked my vote to no. sad.gif

Just keep trying to think of new suggestions for the trading grounds. If you keep thinking you will then catch on to something. wink.gif
Member
Posts: 10,636
Joined: Jul 5 2006
Gold: 4,279.00
May 21 2008 02:18am
When a trade of mine is done. I just state Thread Closed.
Go Back To Site Suggestions Archive Topic List
Closed New Topic New Poll