d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > d2jsp > Site Suggestions > Site Suggestions Archive >
Poll > Introduce A Feedback System Like On E-bay!
Prev123
Closed New Topic New Poll
  Guests cannot view or vote in polls. Please register or login.
Member
Posts: 651
Joined: Dec 6 2007
Gold: Locked
Trader: Scammer
Warn: 40%
Dec 7 2007 06:03am
no from me
i think this would be abused
Member
Posts: 13,596
Joined: May 20 2006
Gold: 14,015.00
Dec 7 2007 06:06am
Quote (Master3921 @ Fri, Dec 7 2007, 11:37am)
that's exactly why we don't have such a system


edit : I can also add somebody threaten to add a negative remark which marks poofed item, though it didn't poof AT ALL, in order to regain my fg - easy scammed fg


so abuseable


Well the main objection to my idea seems to be that the system will be too easy to abuse. I think that fear is overrated since almost every big trading site on internet has a feedback system and obviously they wouldnt have them around if they had serious abuse problems. There needs to be a balance between the seller and the buyer for a trading system to work. Right now there is very little a buyer can do to warn others about dishonest sellers and therefore the system benefits the seller too much. Remember that this is the internet and the only way to know if your dealing with a scammer or honest user is to watch their past behaviour towards other users. If no trade history(= feedback comments) is available then you are sitting duck!

Also if a single user that dislikes you or tries to blackmail you for a refund gives you negative feedback it wont really matter for your reputation but if 10 different well established users report you sold them unperms as perm then obviously it is unlikely they are all lying, wouldnt you agree?

I have yet to hear good arguments against this. Good arguments would be if for instance maybe the site load on this site cant handle this system or maybe it would mean too much coding work for Njaguar to be realistic.

This post was edited by Yan[gg]ua on Dec 7 2007 06:08am
Member
Posts: 12,093
Joined: Sep 30 2003
Gold: 79,443.75
Dec 7 2007 07:02am
Quote (Yan[gg]ua @ Thu, 6 Dec 2007, 13:24)
The problem I am addressing is unperm items being sold to other users as perm. This is a curse making it hard to trade expensive items on this site. We all know that a person's join date and post count isnt a very good way to decide whether he can be trusted to sell you perm or not so another feature is needed. Also moderators cant really help with this sort of thing since there is never any proofs an item poofed on you and moderators cant read guys' minds.

I think a feedback system like the one in place for E-bay trading would be real nice for this site. If you see a user has several negative feedback comments from other users its easy to say he cant be trusted and sellers will be more willing to settle disputes with buyers than today to avoid negative feedback. Dunnow whether this system would require too much work to implement to be worth it but it would make it a safer place for trading for sure.


this was discussed over over and over and over over over over again

don't you guys get it?


no

This post was edited by jacob1818 on Dec 7 2007 07:02am
Admin
Posts: 24,840
Joined: Sep 24 2002
Gold: 43,367.72
Trader: Trusted
Dec 7 2007 07:17am
Feedback systems are easy to abuse. No
Go Back To Site Suggestions Archive Topic List
Prev123
Closed New Topic New Poll