I got closed these 2 topics:

http://forums.d2jsp.org/topic.php?t=59126444&f=103&o=110
http://forums.d2jsp.org/topic.php?t=59100678&f=103

due to excessive spam.. I don't feel like I spammed the thread..I just answered to some question/opinion about chars.. it's a trophy topic and I guess it should be allowed to TALK about the char posted.. btw they were paid topic :/

pm junior mod,they handle that forum: http://forums.d2jsp.org/staff.php?g=20

ok I asked a mod and he re-opened!

thx

t/c

he closed again because there's 1 dupe item in that pic.......


Isn't that unfair? I agree that posting in trophy room a pic with only dupes is senseless... but if there's ONE dupe and 10 legits should be closed anyway?

the duped item itself isn't a trophy (like isn't a trophy an unique item) but if you show an entire char you should be allowed to post few uniques/dupes aslong as they are a small % of the char equip..

The Trophy Room Rules are clear about this. Do not post duped items.

I know about rules.. just asking why? Does it look fair for you? Have u ever asked yourself the reason of that rule?

because everyone would post alot of chars using nothing but duped items making it not so trophy and more or less lame

This is not the place to discuss the fairness or unfairness of specific rules. If you have a legitimate site suggestion, post it here and calmly elaborate on what change you would like to see to the site and why. Just posting "rule X is unfair" will get your topic closed!

I'm talking about a small % of the char equip.. in classic every top-line char needs at least one of two prelod items to work



I'm asking why is there that rule? And u come here just posting the general rules..I don't need such answers.. I wanted opinion about "reason" of that rule..

I'll post on that forum soon..

Agreed, I love to see godly builds. It might be true that this isnt the place yet.
and the reason why.. well I can only imagine that ppl dont like to have dupes in a trophy room, because it isnt a trophy.
Apart from that, there are items which are illegal to trade. If we cant trade them, they shouldnt be in the trophy room as well.

Eventhough a dupe, bugged item, unique or a magic items is never a trophy, it can be part of the bigger picture.
In classic non-ladder the best chars, the most amazing equipped chars, all have one or two dupes as a part of the build.
It is allowed to trade these dupes in the trading forum. So why isnt it allowed to show them in the trophy room?

It is possible to show a unique in the trophy room as part of a build, eventhough a unique is a basic item, not a trophy! It falls under the rule below:
Do NOT post: basic items (potions, gold, quest items, runes etc.)

Im pretty sure we all agree that an unique should be allowed to be there as part of a build.
Shouldnt we also agree that a dupe is allowed to be there as well? As part of a build?



This post was edited by Knaapie on Dec 21 2011 08:20am