Quote (Republican @ Jul 10 2012 12:43am)
lol it could be a coincidence
This is one game, i'm more than open to the idea of a coincidence before trashing someones reputation.
Find 5+ replays of things like this happening and then we have enough to start an ACCUSATION -imo
Or find something that can't be brushed off as a coincidence
There are 2 other replays of him in that thread, after one of them this dude wrote this:
Quote
After reviewing this replay, I must admit there is sufficient suspicious activity.
The overlord you send down to the 5 oclock position, is typical, to scout for an expansion (or even if the player is in that starting location). The overlord you send towards the 10 oclock position, you rally dead center above the 12oclock base. Why not send it further and poke in to see if he spawned there? You can safely check the gas there. Seems like you knew he wasn't there, but were leaving an overlord there for any potential drop scouting.
At 5:10, you poke in to check for the expansion. Typical terran fast expand timing. If it's worth poking in here, why isn't it worth poking in at the 10oclock base?
At 8:08, you see banshees. You don't have lair, and your evos don't start till 9:30ish. I don't know timings that well, but he had more than enough gas to get cloak when he started his first banshee, so obviously it was a possibility. If he started it when the first banshee was being made, it would have hit at around 9 minutes. Somehow that didn't feel like a threat to warrant an evo/lair earlier?
At 9:57, you select your lings, move them, and then bring them STRAIGHT back to your base, just at the top of your ramp, before you see any units coming. Why would you take all your units that are giving you map control, and bring them to your base? A second later, you select both your queens in the natural, move them together, to get ready to defend against the banshees. Spidey sense tingling? You get a perfect flank and surround on the hellions, plus kill a banshee.
At 17:02, you had your infestors selected, and were already looking at where the banshees were going to emerge from the fog of war, ready to fungal. Last you seen the banshees was at the watch tower. Spidey sense again I assume.
At 19:37, you preemptively move your lings back to your base thats about to be dropped. You move them towards the xel'naga watch tower (can't find the point of click for the move command). This is just weird. Why don't you have a ling on the watch tower? Why did you bring them back from the left side of the map?
At 25:17, you have view of a drop for a splitsecond, but don't react to it, assuming you didn't see it during that split second. At 25:32, the millisecond that red shows on your minimap, you are moving your camera there, followed by your units. Possible, but super fishy.
At 27:19 you start moving your lings to scout the 7oclock base (which he has), even though your burrowed ling knows there is no 4th at the 6oclock. Spidey sense again I assume. (At 23:08 it appears like you take a ling and start moving it towards the 6oclock, to try and spot his floating cc, but fail to do so)
After that I decided to see the replays I have of him, first one I load up is the one in that VOD hah