i think its unfair to compare Brady to P.Manning as the bigger brother has WAY more weapons than brady ...( & obv they are 1a 1b IN QB RANKINGS )

and according to xNoz Eli manning has the best trio in the NFL & an AMAZING running game ..

& Brandon Myers ..

who does tom brady have ?

Amendola who has never had more than 700 yards

Aaron Dobson- A rookie who has no experience against legit CBs

Josh Boyce- Another rookie

Julian Edelman who is Average AT BEST ..

KenBrell Thompkins- An undrafted rookie

Zach Sudfield - A Rookie TE for 6 weeks ( Baby Gronk )

So who in your opinion will put up better numbers?

This post was edited by xoxocrazi on Aug 18 2013 08:33pm

Lol.. Brady

I autodrafted a league yesterday and I'm unhappy with having Eli, I wouldn't have the same reaction if I had Brady.

lol what

ESPN autopicked my QB as Eli Manning. This made me sad.

If ESPN had autopicked my QB as Tom Brady I would not be sad.

TROLLOLOLOL like this poll isn't going to be one sided regardless who you put him up against LOL


The play calling is apples and oranges and of course Brady is the better QB.


This should be Eli's best season but we're not designed to have a sexy offense under Coughlin and Gibride.
The O-line worries me and the play calling... lol

Wasn't one sided when they put big brother against him..... was actually just about even last I looked.

Gotta do a more comparable poll like Eli vs Flacco or Eli vs Romo or Brady vs elite qb

I hear Cam Cameron is looking for work.