d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > Sports Coliseum > Football & Rugby >
Poll > Will Mike Mccarthy Get Extended Or Move On
Prev12345610Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Views: 1011Replies: 99Track Topic
  Guests cannot view or vote in polls. Please register or login.
Member
Posts: 23,451
Joined: Jan 7 2009
Gold: Locked
Trader: Scammer
Warn: 80%
#31
Dec 27 2017 01:04pm
Quote (OtterJethro @ Dec 27 2017 03:01pm)
Get ride of him, great coaches are a dime a dozen anyways...


Get ride of him
Member
Posts: 21,576
Joined: May 22 2014
Gold: 0.00
#32
Dec 27 2017 01:08pm
Quote (Acuity @ Dec 27 2017 01:36pm)
You make it seem like they’re losing football games because they are being out coached. They are losing football games because there drafting has been absolutely terrible and they lose free agency every year add that to the fact that they are plauged with injuries and you have a recipe for disaster.


You’re saying that under Hue Jackson they would have the same record or let’s say Chuck Pagano?


they aren't losing games because of McCarthy. he is a portion of the problem, not a big one either, but still not a good HC.

Quote (Cheesehead @ Dec 27 2017 01:40pm)
You're not worth conversing with or even quoting, Malidry. Surprised you haven't made any more personal attacks outside of calling names. That's your bread and butter. Glad to have you in this section, buddy.


there's other people in the thread aside from me, you'd make a great politician avoiding answering the question several times but maintaining that you have the answers and that your opposition is wrong

This post was edited by Giannis on Dec 27 2017 01:09pm
Banned
Posts: 14,932
Joined: Apr 13 2017
Gold: 3.69
Warn: 10%
#33
Dec 27 2017 01:11pm
Whole team on IR every year and they're still really good. Might be the best coach in the NFL. :locked:
Member
Posts: 23,451
Joined: Jan 7 2009
Gold: Locked
Trader: Scammer
Warn: 80%
#34
Dec 27 2017 01:15pm
I'd probably take McCarthy over Tomlin. 2 more postseason wins (though Tomlin will get 1 more post season W in 2018) and doesn't make a clown of himself as often. (Both 1x superbowl, both 6x division champs).
Member
Posts: 40,273
Joined: Mar 29 2006
Gold: 13.00
#35
Dec 27 2017 01:18pm
Quote (Giannis @ Dec 27 2017 12:08pm)
they aren't losing games because of McCarthy. he is a portion of the problem, not a big one either, but still not a good HC.



there's other people in the thread aside from me, you'd make a great politician avoiding answering the question several times but maintaining that you have the answers and that your opposition is wrong



He is probably top 10 coach in the NFL. So I don’t understand how you’re saying that he isn’t good. Is it because he’s not the best coach or what do you mean?

There are 32 teams name the coaches in order that are better than him really quick.
Member
Posts: 21,576
Joined: May 22 2014
Gold: 0.00
#36
Dec 27 2017 01:20pm
Quote (WatcherOfTheSkies @ Dec 27 2017 02:15pm)
I'd probably take McCarthy over Tomlin. 2 more postseason wins (though Tomlin will get 1 more post season W in 2018) and doesn't make a clown of himself as often. (Both 1x superbowl, both 6x division champs).


every young brilliant coordinator would line up to be Rodgers' HC. I don't want to miss out on the next Shanahan or McVay so we can maintain continuity with McCarthy.

bad clock management, poor challenges, bad decision making with games on the line... I don't see how any Packers fan could defend him.

Member
Posts: 21,576
Joined: May 22 2014
Gold: 0.00
#37
Dec 27 2017 01:21pm
Quote (Acuity @ Dec 27 2017 02:18pm)
He is probably top 10 coach in the NFL. So I don’t understand how you’re saying that he isn’t good. Is it because he’s not the best coach or what do you mean?

There are 32 teams name the coaches in order that are better than him really quick.


BB, Reid, Carroll, Harbaugh, Quinn, and Tomlin over McCarthy for sure
Banned
Posts: 14,932
Joined: Apr 13 2017
Gold: 3.69
Warn: 10%
#38
Dec 27 2017 01:23pm
Quote (WatcherOfTheSkies @ Dec 27 2017 03:15pm)
I'd probably take McCarthy over Tomlin. 2 more postseason wins (though Tomlin will get 1 more post season W in 2018) and doesn't make a clown of himself as often. (Both 1x superbowl, both 6x division champs).


Tomlin is great, but trash on the jags. He inherented greatness and ran with it. He is good though, just not HoF'r.

Billacheat and geady are a disgrace to the NFL, along with Kraft. And their hidden boi the Commish.

Real talk. :locked:
Member
Posts: 26,417
Joined: Apr 20 2007
Gold: 1,550.01
#39
Dec 27 2017 01:23pm
Quote (Giannis @ Dec 27 2017 12:21pm)
BB, Reid, Carroll, Harbaugh, Quinn, and Tomlin over McCarthy for sure



What...
Member
Posts: 21,576
Joined: May 22 2014
Gold: 0.00
#40
Dec 27 2017 01:25pm
Josh McDaniels would be a very interesting hire. Now he might be promised the NE job and it's a moot point but if he were to leave this is the type of situation he would leave for. He flamed out in Denver but that might have humbled him and taught him some lessons and I think he would be better this time around. The dude can certainly scheme up an offense.
Go Back To Football & Rugby Topic List
Prev12345610Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll

© 2003-2026 d2jsp  Contact