d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > Graphic Design > Signature Design Class - Week 3 > Criticism And Advanced Learning
Prev1234511Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 38,282
Joined: Feb 28 2007
Gold: 537.35
Sep 12 2011 11:45pm
Quote (emsee2 @ Sep 13 2011 01:30am)
showing its more then me putting text on a photo. this is last time i open this thread.

gl to everyone else trying to do the psd learning.


he said it was animated text on a washed out photograph, nowhere did he imply that all you had done to it was put typo onto it :wacko:

e/

sorry for unnecessary comments here magi

This post was edited by Epiphany on Sep 12 2011 11:45pm
Member
Posts: 9,093
Joined: May 19 2006
Gold: 55.80
Sep 13 2011 09:59am
holy shit you guys...

Quote (AF_Mitch_07 @ Sep 12 2011 09:13pm)
Alright. First off i wanna say this was definitely the hardest thing to do, basically what i did was take the psd, hid all the layers, and started unhiding them and tried seeing what they did per layer. Then making your own signature based on what you wanted to do, mixed with what they did haha. Sat down working on this for about 3 hours. not just on the sig but looking for resources and figuring out what the hell to do.

Anyways, based on this.http://i203.photobucket.com/albums/aa185/AF_Mitch_07/xptag1crop.png

And i made this.http://i203.photobucket.com/albums/aa185/AF_Mitch_07/nportman.png


-the first thing i noticed was the part in the middleish to the left that looks like a dick. not a good idea
-also on the left it is pretty empty, try to add something to make it feel like its got some use
-in the psd there is nothing going over her so shes much cleaner and more hq than yours is
-the colors of yours arent as strong as the tutorial, notice the dark black and white and bright red and how they contrast enough that theres a cool feel to it
+your render is pretty good though, just remember to clean it up
Member
Posts: 7,916
Joined: Jul 14 2007
Gold: 3,935.00
Sep 13 2011 01:06pm
Quote (TheReborn_Magi @ Sep 13 2011 10:59am)
holy shit you guys...



-the first thing i noticed was the part in the middleish to the left that looks like a dick. not a good idea
-also on the left it is pretty empty, try to add something to make it feel like its got some use
-in the psd there is nothing going over her so shes much cleaner and more hq than yours is
-the colors of yours arent as strong as the tutorial, notice the dark black and white and bright red and how they contrast enough that theres a cool feel to it
+your render is pretty good though, just remember to clean it up


lmao i flipped my render horizontally too add more and the arms cutoff+flipped made it look like that, didnt even notice.
I noticed that part and i wasnt sure how to make her stand out like that without ruining the blending on her.
Ill try and fix the colors and clean up some stuff later today.
Thank you
Member
Posts: 7,916
Joined: Jul 14 2007
Gold: 3,935.00
Sep 13 2011 02:56pm
Before
After :D
Member
Posts: 17,374
Joined: Jul 6 2007
Gold: 12,143.67
Sep 13 2011 03:07pm
Quote (AF_Mitch_07 @ Sep 13 2011 12:56pm)
http://i203.photobucket.com/albums/aa185/AF_Mitch_07/nportman.png Before
http://i203.photobucket.com/albums/aa185/AF_Mitch_07/nportman-1.pngAfter :D


overcontrasted and cluttered, there are too many random fx going all over the place for any sort of composition to be present.

after compositional shapes, the best and most frequent way to compose and frame a focal is with contrast. since your tag is covered in dark and lights ALL OVER the place, there is no definite sharp difference in contrast to frame your focal, so the eye wanders. your colors are also very dull and don't mix well. red/oranges framed by whites/blues/purples CAN work, however, it's executed poorly here. take a look at a color wheel, and try to work with complimentary colors for now, almost exclusively, before you advance beyond that.
Member
Posts: 7,916
Joined: Jul 14 2007
Gold: 3,935.00
Sep 13 2011 03:43pm
Quote (nerobellum @ Sep 13 2011 04:07pm)
overcontrasted and cluttered, there are too many random fx going all over the place for any sort of composition to be present.

after compositional shapes, the best and most frequent way to compose and frame a focal is with contrast. since your tag is covered in dark and lights ALL OVER the place, there is no definite sharp difference in contrast to frame your focal, so the eye wanders. your colors are also very dull and don't mix well. red/oranges framed by whites/blues/purples CAN work, however, it's executed poorly here. take a look at a color wheel, and try to work with complimentary colors for now, almost exclusively, before you advance beyond that.


alright will do. im still not sure how to do the contrasting then, since the 1st one was way dull and focal was unclear i duplicated render twice 1 on overlay 1 on lighten to make her stand out more, then for effects i added another splash to the left, then dodged/burned all around to brighten up.
Member
Posts: 6,586
Joined: Apr 1 2009
Gold: 4,628.00
Sep 13 2011 04:22pm
Only have this to offer at the moment, haven't had a lot of time been busy irl. However I did read someone suggesting a color wheel, this one is my favorite...I use it everytime I make a signature. Enjoy!

--> http://colorschemedesigner.com/
Member
Posts: 23,897
Joined: Mar 4 2008
Gold: 535.00
Sep 13 2011 05:11pm
Quote (AF_Mitch_07 @ Sep 14 2011 07:56am)
http://i203.photobucket.com/albums/aa185/AF_Mitch_07/nportman.png Before
http://i203.photobucket.com/albums/aa185/AF_Mitch_07/nportman-1.pngAfter :D


Member
Posts: 9,093
Joined: May 19 2006
Gold: 55.80
Sep 13 2011 05:25pm
Quote (sicklad @ Sep 13 2011 07:11pm)
http://i.imgur.com/kBUY0.jpg


That might of been funny if we didnt already tall about that. Dont add to the spam in my classes
Member
Posts: 47,052
Joined: Jul 1 2008
Gold: 13,845.00
Sep 13 2011 05:39pm

i downloaded some psds i think this was a psd called lipton? from crownzero
this is as far as i got before i got bored and decided to do something else :/
omg right side looks posterized as hell
Q_______________Q



This post was edited by killkillkillkil on Sep 13 2011 05:46pm
Go Back To Graphic Design Topic List
Prev1234511Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll